Can You Trust Mental Health Advice Online? Memory, Authority and TikTok

I learned a claim about the nervous system during training and, for a long time, repeated it as if it were knowledge of my own. Even after I began to understand that I could not find evidence for it in the form in which it had been taught, the old certainty did not disappear at once. I could still repeat the claim automatically, with the feeling that it was something I knew. I had to keep questioning and correcting it.

This was not a false memory of an event that never happened. It was a claim I had absorbed and continued to experience as knowledge. That distinction is one reason I wanted to write about false memories, misinformation and the way we decide what to trust.

My own story began on Instagram. I came across a mental health practitioner’s blog there and later attended their training. At the time, I understood them to be medically qualified. They had shown a medical diploma and had worked as a doctor earlier in their career. Their professional background mattered to me; I was not taking advice from an anonymous account.

During the training, one explanation of the nervous system was presented as a formula that applied to everyone. It was linked to ideas I was learning in my professional training, including CBT. I want to be clear that I am talking about one particular claim and how it was taught, not CBT as a whole. We were not given references or further reading, and I did not think to ask for them.

I also thought I could see a short-term effect in practice. That seemed to support the explanation. Looking back, I can see that an apparent effect made the formula feel more convincing to me, but it did not establish that the explanation behind it was true or universal.

Later, after further training and experience, I went back to the formula and looked for support in academic and clinical sources. I could not find evidence for it in the universal form in which it had been presented to me. I then revisited the professional information I had relied on. In the relevant public records and sources I could access, I could not verify that they were registered or practising as a doctor at the time I searched. They had told us that they had completed two doctoral theses. For one, they showed a photograph of a title page bearing the thesis title and university name; I could not find independent evidence that the thesis had been completed or published. For the second, they named a university and described the subject, but I could not find a record linking them to that university or confirming a thesis on that subject. I was therefore unable to independently verify either thesis.

That describes the limits of what I was able to verify; it does not prove that the qualifications or earlier experience never existed. What changed for me was that I began to separate what I had been told, what I could check, and what remained uncertain. I had paid attention to who was speaking. I had not checked the evidence for that particular claim.

I do not use TikTok myself, so I am not writing from personal experience of the app. I am drawing on research and expert reviews. My reason for bringing TikTok into the discussion is that it is one current place where people encounter mental health advice. My own experience began on Instagram, but the larger question applies across social media: when does an idea start to feel like something we know, and how can we check where it came from?

Memory is reconstructed, not replayed

Memory is not a video recording that we replay exactly as it happened. Remembering involves reconstruction, and research has shown that information encountered before or after an event can affect what people later report remembering. That does not mean that every memory is unreliable. It means that confidence alone cannot tell us whether every detail is accurate.

In a well-known 1995 experiment, Henry Roediger and Kathleen McDermott gave people lists of related words such as bed, rest and awake. The word sleep was not on the list, but participants sometimes recalled it anyway. In the second experiment, the false-recall rate for these related but absent words was 55%. This was a specific laboratory task: it shows one way memory can produce a confident-seeming error, not that people generally invent whole events.

Elizabeth Loftus and John Palmer showed people films of car accidents and then asked questions using different verbs. People asked how fast the cars were going when they “smashed” into each other gave higher estimates than those asked when they “contacted” each other — around 41 miles per hour compared with 32. Those figures were participants’ estimates, not the cars’ measured speed. In a later question, the wording also affected whether some people said they had seen broken glass that had not appeared in the film.

In another study, researchers used a fabricated advertisement suggesting that visitors to Disneyland might meet Bugs Bunny. Of the participants who saw the Bugs Bunny version, 16% later said they remembered shaking hands with him as a child; the figure was 7% in comparison conditions. Bugs Bunny is a Warner Bros character. This is a striking example, but it came from a particular study and a particular suggestion. It is not evidence that any video can implant any memory in anyone.

These examples are often discussed under the broad heading of false memories and misinformation. They are not all the same effect, and none of them is a direct test of what happens when someone watches mental health content on TikTok.

What we know and do not know about social media

In 2025, The Guardian asked psychiatrists, psychologists and academics to review 100 popular TikTok videos posted with the hashtag #mentalhealthtips. The experts judged that 52 contained at least some misinformation. That was a review of a particular sample of videos, not a measure of every mental health post on TikTok.

A 2026 systematic review of 27 studies, analysing more than 5,000 social media posts, found that information quality varied substantially across studies and platforms. The reported prevalence of misinformation ranged from 0% to 56.9%, with higher levels found in TikTok content than in YouTube content in the studies reviewed. The variation matters: it tells us that the quality of information is uneven, not that every video is wrong.

Research on repetition offers one possible link to my own experience. A 2026 meta-analysis of 182 studies found a small average increase in how truthful people judged repeated statements to be, while also finding considerable variation between studies. This is often called the illusory truth effect. It is not proof that TikTok caused my belief, or that repeated videos create false memories. It does help explain why a claim encountered more than once may start to feel familiar and why familiarity can be mistaken for evidence.

Social media can be useful. People find language for experiences, hear from others with similar lives and discover support they might not otherwise encounter. You do not have to delete an app to approach its advice thoughtfully. A useful first step is to pause when a video makes a psychological claim feel suddenly obvious and ask: Is this a personal experience, a professional opinion, or a claim supported by research? Where could I check it?

A note about trauma and memory

If you have lived through war, violence, displacement or another frightening experience, this article is not asking you to doubt what happened to you. Laboratory studies of memory do not let us judge whether a particular person’s account of trauma is true or false.

A review of research on traumatic memories found that most studies concluded that memories of trauma were broadly as accurate among people with PTSD as among people without PTSD, although the research also found changes in how memories may be recalled over time. This does not mean every detail is always available or exact. It does mean that “trauma makes people’s memories false” is not a fair conclusion.

UK guidance for asylum interviews also recognises that trauma can affect a person’s ability to recall some details and that memory should not be treated as a simple test. The substance of an account may matter more than precise dates or exact wording. This guidance is for asylum decision-making, but it is a useful reminder to approach trauma narratives with care rather than suspicion.

Three things worth checking

When you encounter a confident claim about mental health, it can help to check three separate things:

  1. Who is making the claim? What training or role do they describe, and can you verify it through an appropriate professional register or organisation? In the UK, the relevant register depends on the title and service. For example, doctors can be checked through the General Medical Council and practitioner psychologists using protected titles through the Health and Care Professions Council. Many counsellors and psychotherapists choose to join voluntary registers accredited by the Professional Standards Authority. If a practitioner works in another country, check the relevant system there.

  2. What exactly are they claiming? A person can have relevant qualifications and still make a claim that goes beyond the evidence. Look for references to research, clinical guidance or a recognised source, and check what those sources actually say.

  3. What kind of evidence is being offered? A personal story or a short-term change may be meaningful, but it does not by itself establish that a proposed explanation is true for everyone.

For general information about mental health, the NHS, Mind and other established health organisations can be useful places to check. When a claim is specific to your situation, a qualified professional can help you think it through without assuming that a social media label or a single video explains everything.

I am Iryna, an integrative and trauma-informed therapist, an NCPS Accredited Registrant, and a Ukrainian refugee. I offer online therapy to adults in the UK and internationally in English, Ukrainian and Russian. If you would like to talk through something that has stayed with you, you are welcome to book a free introductory consultation through the “Book Now” button on my website.

Common questions

Can social media create false memories?

Memory research shows that suggestions and later information can influence what people report remembering. The research discussed here does not establish that TikTok or other social media routinely create false memories about trauma or personal events.

Does trauma make memories unreliable?

No simple rule like that is supported by the research. People may find some details difficult to recall, and recollection can change over time, but that does not mean a person’s account of trauma is generally false.

Can I trust mental health advice on TikTok?

Some content may be helpful, and some may be misleading or oversimplified. Check who is making the claim, whether they provide sources, and whether trusted health organisations or professional guidance support it.

How do I check a therapist’s qualifications in the UK?

Ask which professional body or register they belong to, then check the register itself. The appropriate register depends on their title and professional role. PSA accreditation applies to a register and its standards; it is not a guarantee that a particular therapy will work for every person.

Sources

Next
Next

Distraction or Avoidance? How to Tell When Coping Is Keeping You Stuck